Start 30 days free, no card. Full Pro access for a month, then decide. Start free

Back to analysts list

Analyst

Chris Bottiglieri

BNP Paribas · covers Consumer Cyclical, Consumer Defensive

Period: Reporting periods mapped to calendar 2024 Q4 – 2026 Q3 (8 quarters; questions recorded in 7).

Questions
23on tracked calls
Challenge rate
9%2 of 23 questions
Companies
4questioned at least once
Reporting periods
7with questions

These figures cover the whole profile: every tracked question, all reporting periods.

How to read these numbers

Challenge rate is the share of questions that pushed back, pressed for specifics or questioned management’s assumptions. It describes how questions were asked on the calls tracked here; it does not measure whether any view turned out to be right.

Rounding. Rates are rounded to whole percentages, so a small share can show as 0% even when some questions were challenging. The count beside each rate is exact; “none of N questions” means no question was challenging.

No questions recorded. “—” means there is nothing to calculate: no questions were recorded for that period on the calls tracked here. It does not mean there was no activity.

Fewer than 3 questions. A company-level rate is withheld when fewer than 3 questions were recorded for that company; the questions are still counted everywhere else.

Small samples. Profiles with fewer than 10 questions are marked Limited sample.

Reporting periods. Questions are grouped by the calendar quarter each company’s fiscal reporting period maps to, not by the date of the call. Periods without a calendar mapping are listed separately under their fiscal label.

Questions asked

Grouped by company, most questions first. Open a company to read its questions, newest reporting period first.

Showing 23 of 23 questions from 4 companies

CPRTCopart11 questions · 6 reporting periods · 2 of 11 challenging
CPRT company page →

Calendar 2026 Q3

how should we think about opportunities for future M&A from here?

M&ACapital AllocationTranscript · FY2026 Q4 →
Show response

Adair said the ACV deal does not preclude further auction-space acquisitions given ample remaining cash.

Calendar 2025 Q4

you're gross PP in land is up 155% since 2019. Your volumes are up about 30, let's call it, since then

ChallengingCapex InvestmentMarginTranscript · FY2026 Q1 →
Show response

Leah explained hurricane-dedicated land has lower utilization, skewing the ratio. Areas needing capacity over next 5-10 years is a shorter list than five years ago. Logistics cost optimization another factor in land decisions.

What does it delve into the 38% disparity between international U.S. bidders?

PricingCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2026 Q1 →
Show response

Leah clarified international buyers favor lighter damage, higher value vehicles. Jeff added freight economics mean only worthwhile vehicles get shipped overseas. International buyers are price-setters in roughly half of U.S. auctions.

Calendar 2025 Q3

You had mentioned that you grew your ASPs five times faster than similar service provider. You just kind of elaborate there

Competitive DynamicsPricingTranscript · FY2025 Q4 →
Show response

Jeff confirmed Copart's 5.7% U.S. insurance ASP increase far exceeds competitor disclosures. Chris probed on ARPU and GPU gap versus closest peer, with Jeff affirming superior auction returns.

can you go over the low double-digit decline in assignments? Number? I wanna make sure I have that right

Show response

Leah clarified assignment decline was low single digit, not low double digit. CAT did not play a material role in either period's assignments.

Calendar 2025 Q2

What sets prices in your end markets? Like, is it somehow derived off of US vehicle prices or is it derived by the local economies

Show response

Leah explained the massive affordability gap in emerging markets means international buyers have significant spread. Jeff added it varies by vehicle type from local scrap to globally-traded drivable cars.

what do you currently see from a market share perspective and is there any reason why your peer could be putting higher reporting growth numbers

ChallengingCompetitive DynamicsDemandTranscript · FY2025 Q3 →
Show response

Jeff attributed differential growth to relative growth of individual insurance carriers served. Emphasized focus on delivering best returns and investing in platform rather than tracking share metrics.

Calendar 2025 Q1

are insurers moving all of the units they could sign with you? Are they kind of giving you like a sample at first?

Innovation & R&DCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2025 Q2 →
Show response

Jeff described pilot-to-full adoption pattern. Virtually every Title Express client has migrated all titles. The service builds trust for further workflow outsourcing.

can you just remind us kind of how a strong USD, like how it plays throughout your business? Does it impact the fees buyers pay?

Show response

Jeff explained Copart is net short the dollar. Diversified international buyer base mitigates FX risk as some countries strengthen when others weaken.

Calendar 2024 Q4

was there any noticeable impact on your business from the Trump tariff regime in '18, '19? Did you see impacts on ASP or total loss rates

Trade TariffsPricingTranscript · FY2025 Q1 →
Show response

Jeff acknowledged contradictory potential effects from tariffs but said last time around there was not a meaningful disruption to the business.

I was wondering what he's historically seen when there's been changes like from cat events. We have large hurricanes

DemandMacroeconomicTranscript · FY2025 Q1 →
Show response

Jeff said the data is too aggregated to isolate hurricane-specific effects on insurance participation. No attributable change was visible from Hurricane Harvey in 2017.

CVNACarvana Co.8 questions · 4 reporting periods · 0 of 8 challenging
CVNA company page →

Calendar 2025 Q3

it sounds like you're going to reinvest that into the consumer proposition to offer lower rates to the consumer. I just wanted to, a, confirm that

Show response

Confirmed Q4 other GPU will step down to Q4 2024 levels as fundamental gains are shared with customers through lower interest rates.

can you frame for us how performance in Phoenix is doing versus the control market that hasn't seen this type of increase

Innovation & R&DDemandTranscript · FY2025 Q3 →
Show response

Confirmed clear speed-conversion relationship. Positioned same-day delivery as tremendously differentiating and strategically important. Plans to roll out after nailing Phoenix.

Calendar 2025 Q2

Can you kind of talk about that mix shift into more expensive vehicles and kind of what's going on there?

Show response

Attributed ASP increase to algorithms tracking real-time supply/demand. Expected further ASP increase in Q3 but could decline after. Focus on units and profitability, not ASP.

Does this primarily relate to the expansion selection or the change in the agreement with the commercial party just have an accounting impact

InventoryCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2025 Q2 →
Show response

Identified three inventory growth drivers: sales/selection growth, contract structure change with marketplace partner, and higher average vehicle costs.

Calendar 2025 Q1

what are the steps you do differently to hit it in 5 years versus 10? Like how does that change your capacity needs

Capex InvestmentRevenue GrowthTranscript · FY2025 Q1 →
Show response

10-year path requires ~90 units/week production growth, 5-year requires ~180 units/week. Currently averaging 80 across 23 sites, expanding to ~60.

it sounded like you recast the TAM to the $40 million used plus new, and now you're 1% of that TAM

Competitive DynamicsRevenue GrowthTranscript · FY2025 Q1 →
Show response

Acknowledged franchise dealership acquisition but declined to elaborate. Described as experimenting and learning stage.

Calendar 2024 Q4

what the go-forward strategy is on loan sales. It looks like the fixed loan sales stepped up to $700 million this quarter

Capital AllocationCreditTranscript · FY2024 Q4 →
Show response

Confirmed continuation of diversified loan monetization across whole loan sales and securitization. Strong demand for loans.

looks like there was a one-time item in other SG&A. It looks like you didn't adjust it out to add it back to EBITDA

MarginCost PressureTranscript · FY2024 Q4 →
Show response

Explained $9M thank you bonus spread across cost-of-sales, operations, and overhead. Not backed out of EBITDA consistent with policy on small non-recurring items.

DLTRDollar Tree2 questions · 1 reporting period · 0 of 2 challenging
DLTR company page →

Calendar 2026 Q2

Can you give us an update on the tariff refunds and how you're thinking about timing, amount and the use of the proceeds?

Trade TariffsCapital AllocationTranscript · FY2026 Q1 →
Show response

Mike said they would reinvest refunds in the business but provided no timing or amount, noting nothing is in the outlook.

Can you speak to what you were seeing from low-income consumer given elevated gas prices?

DemandMacroeconomicTranscript · FY2026 Q1 →
Show response

Mike confirmed trade-in customers skewing higher-income; Stewart said the low-income consumer is pressured but all income cohorts comped positive.

ORLYO'Reilly Automotive2 questions · 1 reporting period · 0 of 2 challenging
ORLY company page →

Calendar 2025 Q1

How long does it take to move sourcing? Is there anything to get to help the first five points of sourcing? That you move and made it easier?

Supply ChainTrade TariffsTranscript · FY2025 Q1 →
Show response

Brent confirmed ongoing diversification to India, Vietnam, Thailand with proprietary brands enabling multi-supplier sourcing. Jeremy cautioned against moving too fast, wanting strategic clarity on long-term tariff regime before major shifts.

do you have a sense for, like, how your competitors put in the private side? Are they sourcing generally from the same suppliers and countries of origin

Competitive DynamicsSupply ChainTranscript · FY2025 Q1 →
Show response

Brent described a mixed bag of shared and exclusive suppliers. Confirmed confidence in supply chain nimbleness and ability to source as good or better than anyone in the industry based on positioning.

Challenge rate by company

Every company this analyst questioned, most questions first. A company-level rate is shown from 3 questions; below that it is withheld.

CompanyQuestionsChallenge rate
CPRT Copart1118%2 of 11 questions
CVNA Carvana Co.80%none of 8 questions
DLTR Dollar Tree2—Rate withheld: fewer than 3 questions
ORLY O'Reilly Automotive2—Rate withheld: fewer than 3 questions
  • CPRT
    Copart · 11 questions
    18%2 of 11 questions
  • CVNA
    Carvana Co. · 8 questions
    0%none of 8 questions
  • DLTR
    Dollar Tree · 2 questions
    —rate withheld: under 3 questions
  • ORLY
    O'Reilly Automotive · 2 questions
    —rate withheld: under 3 questions

Activity by reporting period

Questions recorded for each calendar quarter that companies’ reporting periods map to (not the call date), with the challenge rate for that period. Periods inside the range with no questions are shown as “No questions recorded”.

Questions by calendar reporting period
Calendar periodQuestionsChallenge rateCompanies
2024 Q440%none of 4 questions2
2025 Q160%none of 6 questions3
2025 Q2425%1 of 4 questions2
2025 Q340%none of 4 questions2
2025 Q4250%1 of 2 questions1
2026 Q1No questions recorded——
2026 Q220%none of 2 questions1
2026 Q310%none of 1 question1
  1. 2024 Q44 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 4 questions) · 2 companies
  2. 2025 Q16 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 6 questions) · 3 companies
  3. 2025 Q24 questions · challenge rate 25% (1 of 4 questions) · 2 companies
  4. 2025 Q34 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 4 questions) · 2 companies
  5. 2025 Q42 questions · challenge rate 50% (1 of 2 questions) · 1 company
  6. 2026 Q1No questions recorded
  7. 2026 Q22 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 2 questions) · 1 company
  8. 2026 Q31 question · challenge rate 0% (none of 1 question) · 1 company

Topics

Topics tagged on this analyst’s questions.

  • Competitive Dynamics7
  • Demand7
  • Pricing6
  • Capital Allocation3
  • Margin3
  • Trade Tariffs3
  • Capex Investment2
  • Macroeconomic2
  • Credit2
  • Innovation & R&D2
Show all 16 topics
  • Revenue Growth2
  • Supply Chain2
  • M&A1
  • Fx1
  • Inventory1
  • Cost Pressure1