Start 30 days free, no card. Full Pro access for a month, then decide. Start free
Analyst
Eric Serotta
Period: Reporting periods mapped to calendar 2024 Q4 – 2026 Q3 (8 quarters).
- Questions
- 37on tracked calls
- Challenge rate
- 5%2 of 37 questions
- Companies
- 5questioned at least once
- Reporting periods
- 8with questions
These figures cover the whole profile: every tracked question, all reporting periods.
How to read these numbers
Challenge rate is the share of questions that pushed back, pressed for specifics or questioned management’s assumptions. It describes how questions were asked on the calls tracked here; it does not measure whether any view turned out to be right.
Rounding. Rates are rounded to whole percentages, so a small share can show as 0% even when some questions were challenging. The count beside each rate is exact; “none of N questions” means no question was challenging.
No questions recorded. “—” means there is nothing to calculate: no questions were recorded for that period on the calls tracked here. It does not mean there was no activity.
Fewer than 3 questions. A company-level rate is withheld when fewer than 3 questions were recorded for that company; the questions are still counted everywhere else.
Small samples. Profiles with fewer than 10 questions are marked Limited sample.
Reporting periods. Questions are grouped by the calendar quarter each company’s fiscal reporting period maps to, not by the date of the call. Periods without a calendar mapping are listed separately under their fiscal label.
Questions asked
Grouped by company, most questions first. Open a company to read its questions, newest reporting period first.
Showing 37 of 37 questions from 5 companies
PMPhilip Morris International12 questions · 6 reporting periods · 1 of 12 challenging
Calendar 2026 Q2
We definitely saw a pickup in promotional activity over the past year from some of your competitors.
Show response
Babeau said every player is focused on absorbing the excise pass-on rather than promotions, PMI held share broadly (68 vs 69), and declined to comment on competitor strategy or its own October pricing application.
Calendar 2026 Q1
how much of a priority is that with your margins at very high levels and a lot of growth potential ahead
Show response
CEO confirmed volume maximization is the priority over margin harvesting, noting IQOS delivers 2x+ revenue and gross profit per unit vs. combustible. Direct acknowledgment of the trade-off.
the trade-off between pricing and market share that you're willing to win to balance in terms of U.S.
Show response
CEO reiterated ZYN's premium positioning but declined to elaborate on specific pricing actions, calling it a 'very sensitive matter.' Acknowledged need to monitor competitive gaps.
Calendar 2025 Q4
'26 does not include anything for Oluma in The US. But there is something included for the you know, sort of 2728 time frame? Is that fair?
Show response
Olczak confirmed IQOS US is included in the medium-term algorithm including both investment and expected volumes, but stated the targets are not materially dependent on it.
in terms of ICOS, HTU, shipments, and IMS. Obviously, there's the, some of the specific headwinds you you called out in terms of, the excise in Japan
Show response
Emmanuel highlighted broad IQOS momentum across Europe (Italy, Germany, Spain, Romania, Bulgaria) and new markets (Taiwan 4% share in weeks), while declining to give Japan-specific volume guidance citing competitive sensitivity.
Calendar 2025 Q3
with you know, sort of the extraordinary promos of September having eased a bit in October, We've seen the scanner data at least weaken in October. Not all that surprising, but maybe a little bit s...
Show response
Emmanuel confirmed October offtake remains at 30%+ growth, consistent with Q3 ex-free-can levels, indicating the September spike was promotional and underlying demand remains robust.
on the IQOS business, you provide some additional color on the mismatch between HTU shipments and IMS. I know there was a pretty tough comp on the IMS side of close to 15%. But any additional color...
Show response
Emmanuel quantified the gap at ~12% shipments vs ~10% IMS, attributed to timing and inventory build. Expects Q4 alignment with shipments potentially slightly below IMS for the year.
Calendar 2025 Q2
Are you guys still sticking to your expectation of a second half authorization
Show response
Emmanuel noted FDA is resuming PMTA activity and scheduled advisory committees, but acknowledged ILUMA authorization could slip to 2026 given heavy FDA workload.
Your volumes down one and a half percent, or I should say only one and a half percent despite the headwinds you called out
Show response
Emmanuel confirmed ~2% full-year decline is the expected long-term trend for combustibles, with H2 decline of 3-4% against high prior year comparison, half attributable to Turkey.
Calendar 2025 Q1
Are you seeing different trends or diverging trends when you look at some of the non-track channels
Show response
Emmanuel cautioned that Nielsen covers only 3,000 of ~200,000 sales points, and out-of-stock creates distortion. MSA data showing strong acceleration in March was the most reliable alternative datapoint.
Are there any specific offsets that you could point to that caused you to reiterate the guidance
Show response
Emmanuel cited macro uncertainty after just one quarter, noting ZYN volume raise of 20M cans is positive but not enough to dramatically change the full-year outlook.
How are you guys thinking about what the unconstrained growth for what the unconstrained offtake growth for ZYN
Show response
Emmanuel acknowledged inability to quantify unconstrained demand but expects acceleration as availability improves and commercial/marketing initiatives reactivate beyond existing consumer base.
MOAltria10 questions · 6 reporting periods · 0 of 10 challenging
Calendar 2026 Q2
in terms of on! PLUS any insights as to what you're seeing in terms of consumer sourcing?
Show response
Described sourcing across on! classic, competitive pouches and MST consumers, and said the company is agnostic to cannibalization within the on! family.
Hoping you could give some color into how you're thinking about portfolio mix between discount and premium
Show response
Newman explained the RGM framework and the L&M precedent for discount participation but gave no quantified mix impact.
Calendar 2026 Q1
how you're thinking about the potential macro impact from the low end -- from the low-end consumer.
Show response
Sal acknowledged gas price spikes pressuring discretionary spending, with tax-refund tailwinds short-term, driving discount-segment growth managed via RGM.
Calendar 2025 Q4
increased in smoking incense among younger, 20, legal-aged, nicotine users
Show response
Billy dismissed reports of rising youth smoking as inconsistent with their data. Emphasized need for FDA to authorize smoke-free products and educate consumers on relative risk.
can you talk or provide any color on what you're doing here that may be apart from the KT and G partnership
Show response
Billy framed the drawback opportunity as capped by export-import matching. Won't specify individual partner details but will continue seeking relationships to avoid competitive disadvantage.
Calendar 2025 Q3
Could you talk a bit about the price point as you launch in the 3 states
Show response
Billy positioned on! PLUS as premium product commanding higher price due to consumer differentiation. Will have introductory promotions initially.
Calendar 2025 Q2
There have been several press stories about shortages for particular leading brands or products of illicit products
Show response
Billy noted brand substitution is easy in illicit market. Manufacturers change brand names and packaging. Seeing misdeclaration of shipments to evade Customs.
has your view in terms of the ability to compete in vape and sort of the timing of when you would be able to come back to market really changed
Show response
Billy reiterated discipline on timing. Pod segment is shrinking while disposables grow. Will bring NJOY back when appropriate but market state hasn't changed.
Calendar 2024 Q4
you called out a somewhat lower tax rate and lower pension income. Are there any other items that we should think of
Show response
Management noted tax rate is favorable YoY and pension income is lower due to market performance. Sal emphasized mid-single digit is a CAGR with expected annual variability.
wondering if you have any color as to what you're seeing with respect to your consumer in those channels
Show response
Billy noted lower-income consumers react immediately to economic conditions and have been unable to adjust to cumulative inflation. If inflation moderates, consumers should adjust.
BF-BBrown–Forman6 questions · 6 reporting periods · 0 of 6 challenging
Calendar 2026 Q3
How much of a dent do you guys think that that has made in aging stocks and mature whiskey to date?
Show response
Lawson: BF is not overextended (international/RTD/flavors moved inventory); industry new fills down 30% in 2025 and likely again, craft distilleries roughly halved to ~2,000 -- supply coming off.
Calendar 2026 Q2
can you just give us a little bit of an update as to the Blackberry international plans?
Show response
Whiting said Blackberry launched mid-fiscal-2026 in the U.K., Germany, Poland, Chile and France with nice volumes, is part of a planned two-year global rollout leveraging Jack Daniel's international demand, and pointed to Brazil as the most promising market, while noting Honey has reached nearly 2 million cases over 15 years.
Calendar 2026 Q1
Hoping you could delve into the inventory dynamics in a bit more detail. In terms of what happened in the fiscal third quarter
Show response
Cunningham attributed the slight shipment-over-depletion gap to the Blackberry launch and U.S. distributor transitions (2% CDI in the U.S., 5% in emerging international) and expects normalization by year-end. On the Middle East she said team members are safe, the UAE is a strong double-digit growth market with adequate supply, Israel is small, and Travel Retail could see some logistics impact.
Calendar 2025 Q3
What are you seeing in terms of the competitive and promotional environment, last quarter, you commented I think that surprisingly, everyone had been pretty rational thus far
Show response
Lawson confirmed American whiskey pricing flat in last 13 weeks of Nielsen with big players remaining rational. Tequila most aggressive for obvious reasons. Industry supply concerns moderating as thousands of entrepreneurial brands struggling and going out of business, reducing shelf crowding. Highlighted Double Oaked as most successful line extension ever, with 10/12/14-year-old age series demand far exceeding supply.
Calendar 2025 Q1
are you expecting anything unusual or visible in fourth quarter results from RNDC, I guess, selling down inventories, Sazerac building inventories?
Show response
Leanne expects seamless California distributor transition. Finished goods inventory progress significant but muted by tariff mitigation strategies. Emerging market growth is mix of geographic expansion, pricing, and category growth.
Calendar 2024 Q4
earlier this year or late last fiscal year, you did talk about reducing your production to get your finished goods inventories down. Where do you stand today versus your target?
Show response
Leanne confirmed significant progress on inventory reduction visible in lower working capital requirements. Lawson noted industry supply conditions favor big established brands as smaller players struggle.
TAPMolson Coors Beverage Company5 questions · 5 reporting periods · 1 of 5 challenging
Calendar 2025 Q4
Can you give us any context for what kind of quantum you're expecting in terms of reinvestment for 2026 and the midterm
Show response
Rahul said no significant step-up in investment; ensuring brands are competitive and investments drive efficiency/value. Americas restructuring actions taken in Q4, supply chain savings ongoing, EMEA/APAC margin improvement targeted. Tracey cited CapEx reduction from $750M to $650M, working capital opportunities, and confidence in doing all priorities with strong balance sheet and cash generation.
Calendar 2025 Q3
are there areas either that need increased investment or where you need further build out capabilities either from an OpEx or CapEx standpoint
Show response
Rahul identified 3 capability buckets: supply chain (variety packing, flavor capabilities, logistics optimization), commercial capabilities (category captaincy exceeds market share), and technology (AI, baseline infrastructure). All investments evaluated on productivity, efficiency, or top/bottom line enablement.
Calendar 2025 Q2
are there any changes to your marketing or go-to- market strategies that you're implementing or contemplating in light of what seems like a resurgent competitor
Show response
Gavin detailed U.S. share loss breakdown: flavors/seltzer biggest drag (Simply, Vizzy declining), economy portfolio ~1/3, core retained 180bps of step-change gains. Outlined Q3 plans: Miller Lite 50th anniversary, NFL alliance, Coors Light ESPN GameDay, Banquet 'start your legacy' program. Tracey noted incentive comp reversal of large portion accrued in H1, cash tax benefits and working capital largely offset profit shortfall.
Calendar 2025 Q1
just wondering if you could provide some perspective on how you're thinking of category growth over a three-to-five-year time frame
Show response
Gavin reiterated confidence in premiumization plans and goal to reach a third of NSR from above premium. Acknowledged tough Q1 but expects normalization to historical industry trends. Timing uncertain.
Calendar 2024 Q4
could you talk a bit about shelf space expectations for your brands in 2025
Show response
Gavin expects to hold unprecedented shelf gains from 2024 with minor adjustments. Tracey explained Fever-Tree: 100% U.S. revenue recognized, shared marketing costs, royalty in COGS, equity stake at cost marked to market excluded from underlying.
CELHCelsius Holdings, Inc.4 questions · 4 reporting periods · 0 of 4 challenging
Calendar 2026 Q2
some of these gains have been a lot slower than expected in coming. Where are you today versus that original target?
Show response
CFO acknowledged timing slipped, said the large-retailer space came through in July and end-cap/cold-space swaps continue into September and Q4.
Calendar 2025 Q3
how are you thinking about the Alani growth rate on a going-forward basis for sort of the core brand
Show response
John framed Alani growth as strong but lumpy on LTO timing, with distribution and TDP gains to capture through 2026, without a specific rate.
Calendar 2025 Q2
Hoping you could give some color on expectations for Alani shipments versus takeaway.
Show response
Serotta asked about Alani sell-in vs takeaway; Langhans cited ~129% scanner vs shipped growth to show sell-through is real, and flagged Witch's Brew pulled forward, direct.
Calendar 2024 Q4
Does Pepsi have any right of first refusal for distributing other brands that you buy?
Show response
Management deflected the right-of-first-refusal question but Jarrod quantified the Q4 distributor-inventory impact at $8-10 million.
Challenge rate by company
Every company this analyst questioned, most questions first. A company-level rate is shown from 3 questions; below that it is withheld.
| Company | Questions | Challenge rate |
|---|---|---|
| PM Philip Morris International | 12 | 8%1 of 12 questions |
| MO Altria | 10 | 0%none of 10 questions |
| BF-B Brown–Forman | 6 | 0%none of 6 questions |
| TAP Molson Coors Beverage Company | 5 | 20%1 of 5 questions |
| CELH Celsius Holdings, Inc. | 4 | 0%none of 4 questions |
Activity by reporting period
Questions recorded for each calendar quarter that companies’ reporting periods map to (not the call date), with the challenge rate for that period. Periods inside the range with no questions are shown as “No questions recorded”.
| Calendar period | Questions | Challenge rate | Companies |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 Q4 | 5 | 0%none of 5 questions | 4 |
| 2025 Q1 | 5 | 0%none of 5 questions | 3 |
| 2025 Q2 | 6 | 17%1 of 6 questions | 4 |
| 2025 Q3 | 6 | 17%1 of 6 questions | 5 |
| 2025 Q4 | 5 | 0%none of 5 questions | 3 |
| 2026 Q1 | 4 | 0%none of 4 questions | 3 |
| 2026 Q2 | 5 | 0%none of 5 questions | 4 |
| 2026 Q3 | 1 | 0%none of 1 question | 1 |
- 2024 Q45 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 5 questions) · 4 companies
- 2025 Q15 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 5 questions) · 3 companies
- 2025 Q26 questions · challenge rate 17% (1 of 6 questions) · 4 companies
- 2025 Q36 questions · challenge rate 17% (1 of 6 questions) · 5 companies
- 2025 Q45 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 5 questions) · 3 companies
- 2026 Q14 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 4 questions) · 3 companies
- 2026 Q25 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 5 questions) · 4 companies
- 2026 Q31 question · challenge rate 0% (none of 1 question) · 1 company
Topics
Topics tagged on this analyst’s questions.
- Competitive Dynamics20
- Demand14
- Product Launch7
- Pricing6
- Inventory5
- Revenue Growth5
- Regulation Policy4
- Supply Chain3
- Geographic Expansion3
- Capital Allocation3
Show all 17 topics
- Macroeconomic2
- Guidance Reliability2
- Innovation & R&D1
- Margin1
- Cost Pressure1
- Capex Investment1
- M&A1