Start 30 days free, no card. Full Pro access for a month, then decide. Start free

Back to analysts list

Analyst

Rob Ottenstein

Evercore ISI · covers Consumer Defensive

Period: Reporting periods mapped to calendar 2024 Q3 – 2026 Q3 (9 quarters).

Questions
51on tracked calls
Challenge rate
6%3 of 51 questions
Companies
9questioned at least once
Reporting periods
9with questions

These figures cover the whole profile: every tracked question, all reporting periods.

How to read these numbers

Challenge rate is the share of questions that pushed back, pressed for specifics or questioned management’s assumptions. It describes how questions were asked on the calls tracked here; it does not measure whether any view turned out to be right.

Rounding. Rates are rounded to whole percentages, so a small share can show as 0% even when some questions were challenging. The count beside each rate is exact; “none of N questions” means no question was challenging.

No questions recorded. “—” means there is nothing to calculate: no questions were recorded for that period on the calls tracked here. It does not mean there was no activity.

Fewer than 3 questions. A company-level rate is withheld when fewer than 3 questions were recorded for that company; the questions are still counted everywhere else.

Small samples. Profiles with fewer than 10 questions are marked Limited sample.

Reporting periods. Questions are grouped by the calendar quarter each company’s fiscal reporting period maps to, not by the date of the call. Periods without a calendar mapping are listed separately under their fiscal label.

Questions asked

Grouped by company, most questions first. Open a company to read its questions, newest reporting period first.

Showing 51 of 51 questions from 9 companies

PGThe Procter & Gamble Company9 questions · 8 reporting periods · 1 of 9 challenging
PG company page →

Calendar 2026 Q2

I am just wondering if there is anything that is more distinct with Procter's business compared to other of your

ChallengingInventoryDemandMacroeconomicTranscript · FY2026 Q4 →
Show response

Schulten attributed the gap to P&G's scale and velocity rather than strategy; Jejurikar could not isolate a gasoline effect but flagged a top-line multiplier if the Middle East conflict sustains.

Calendar 2026 Q1

give us an update on the restructuring program that you announced in June of last year

Cost PressureInnovation & R&DTranscript · FY2026 Q3 →
Show response

Andre confirmed restructuring is on track across all components: portfolio exits slightly ahead, headcount reduction in line with trajectory, and technology/automation rollouts progressing.

Can you disaggregate the volume number in the quarter for the Easter impact the inventory drawdown last year

Revenue GrowthDemandTranscript · FY2026 Q3 →
Show response

Andre quantified the Q4-to-Q3 pull forward at about 1 point, meaning underlying organic growth would have rounded to 3% rather than a strong 3%. Kept the explanation simple.

Calendar 2025 Q4

how specifically is that impacting your media efficiency and competitive dynamics against smaller brands

Competitive DynamicsInnovation & R&DTranscript · FY2026 Q2 →
Show response

Andre said strongest core plus premium bigger-more innovation drives online; Shailesh cited India e-commerce growing 10x offline as an example of channel focus.

Calendar 2025 Q3

has affordability become a bigger driver of consumer choice in the quarter? Do you expect that to continue

Show response

Andre pushed back on affordability framing; cited premium trade-up, private label declining below 16%, and pack/channel strategies for stretched consumers.

Calendar 2025 Q2

is this a consumer that really wants and needs more affordability, and there were some comments around that

PricingInnovation & R&DTranscript · FY2025 Q4 →
Show response

Jon described pack size strategy, innovation-led cost reduction and pricing ladder fill; pushed back on superiority-equals-premium misperception.

Calendar 2025 Q1

I believe you stated that in China, you were taking pricing in skincare. So I'd like to understand a little bit

PricingCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2025 Q3 →
Show response

Andre said pricing is innovation-led; deflected on retailer private-label strategy commentary.

Calendar 2024 Q4

just wanted to get any commentary on the Chinese consumer, the health of the Chinese consumer as the quarter developed

DemandInnovation & R&DTranscript · FY2025 Q2 →
Show response

Jon declined to quantify innovation but cited confidence from Tide Evo results and whole body deodorant growth.

Calendar 2024 Q3

are there structural changes in the Chinese market or the Chinese consumer that need to be addressed

DemandGeographic ExpansionTranscript · FY2025 Q1 →
Show response

Andre detailed channel, media and benefit shifts and rebuilt distributor partnerships; said SK-II's 'brown shoots' are disappearing, not yet green.

CLColgate-Palmolive7 questions · 7 reporting periods · 0 of 7 challenging
CL company page →

Calendar 2026 Q2

if you could do a bit of a dive on the Chinese market, you know, which is always changing

Competitive DynamicsGeographic ExpansionTranscript · FY2026 Q2 →
Show response

Noel detailed China execution: mid-single-digit Colgate China growth, low-single-digit Darlie growth, and exporting Chinese digital innovation and talent.

Calendar 2026 Q1

I was wondering if you can talk a little bit more about Hill's, which has largely gone unnoticed so far in this call

Revenue GrowthProduct LaunchCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2026 Q1 →
Show response

Noel detailed strong Hill's performance: U.S. up 5%, Prescription Diet double-digit growth, share gains across channels. Private label drag of 260 basis points tapering. Dry dog only weak segment.

Calendar 2025 Q4

I'm wondering if you could kind of reflect on the learnings from that, to what extent you can transfer those learnings to Hawley & Hazel

Geographic ExpansionCompetitive DynamicsCloud & AITranscript · FY2025 Q4 →
Show response

Wallace described active transfer of China omni-demand learnings globally. H&H replicating Colgate China's e-commerce strategy with successful super-premium dual chamber technology launch. Structural changes underway.

Calendar 2025 Q3

If you can give us just a sense of where the market shares ended up with the relaunch and your thought of the impact of the formula change

Product LaunchCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2025 Q3 →
Show response

Wallace said Total got out of gates strong with incremental share gains. Reformulated product rolling in with shares recovering. Drugstore channel challenged but reengaging with retailers on mid-store traffic.

Calendar 2025 Q2

I know the total relaunch had a great start this year, particularly in Latin America

Product LaunchGeographic ExpansionDemandTranscript · FY2025 Q2 →
Show response

Wallace reported strong incremental share from Total relaunch across 75 markets. LatAm seeing consumer cautiousness with Mexico improving slightly but Brazil decelerating. Pricing flowing through in H2.

Calendar 2025 Q1

Can you talk maybe just a little bit about why you are doing so well there, the role of ELMEX in the strategy

Geographic ExpansionCompetitive DynamicsProduct LaunchTranscript · FY2025 Q1 →
Show response

Wallace cited strong market share gains in oral care on both Colgate and Elmex. Elmex expanding selectively into Brazil and Middle East as a 5-10 year strategy, not short-term.

Calendar 2024 Q4

on the Total relaunch. I'm wondering if, first, you can kind of size that compared to other relaunches

Product LaunchCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2024 Q4 →
Show response

Wallace reported terrific share growth from LatAm Total launch. Rolling to Asia, North America, Europe. Meaningful formula upgrade focused on prevention across toothpaste, toothbrush, mouthwash.

KOThe Coca-Cola Company7 questions · 7 reporting periods · 0 of 7 challenging
KO company page →

Calendar 2026 Q2

I was wondering if you could give us any kind of insights into the Marriott contract, which you won after 34 years.

Competitive DynamicsDemandTranscript · FY2026 Q2 →
Show response

Explained the customer-centric shift and portfolio approach but gave no volume sizing or transition timing.

Calendar 2026 Q1

I was wondering if you could go into a little bit more detail on the underlying drivers of your performance in APAC

Geographic ExpansionDemandTranscript · FY2026 Q1 →
Show response

Henrique framed APAC as long-term investment play, highlighted disciplined category selection in China and local brand portfolio in India, acknowledged margin work remains.

Calendar 2025 Q4

Could you maybe remind us your approach to currency?

FxCapital AllocationTranscript · FY2025 Q4 →
Show response

John explained hedging enables consistent local investment while growing USD earnings. Well-hedged on G10 currencies. EM hedging limited by economics. 1% NSR tailwind and 3% net income tailwind for 2026.

Calendar 2025 Q3

I wonder if we can kind of circle back to a topic that was in much discussion a couple of years ago and has faded a little bit is GLP-1 drugs

DemandProduct LaunchTranscript · FY2025 Q3 →
Show response

James confirmed GLP-1 data showing shift away from full sugar toward diet, hydration, coffee and protein. New York capacity on track to ramp through 2026.

Calendar 2025 Q2

can you talk a little bit about globally what you're seeing in terms of consumer strength

DemandMacroeconomicTranscript · FY2025 Q2 →
Show response

James called global consumer resilient overall. ASEAN was the most surprising area of weakness. Events coming in and out at faster velocity than historically.

Calendar 2025 Q1

if you can kind of one talk about the trajectory of that business starting now with kind of the service levels you have

Product LaunchCapex InvestmentTranscript · FY2025 Q1 →
Show response

James clarified growth moderation is percentage-based, not dollar-based. Major capacity coming online year-end. Will enable unconstrained growth and expanded innovation.

Calendar 2024 Q4

I'd love to get your thoughts on that category, broadly speaking. Is this something that is a fad in your view

Competitive DynamicsProduct LaunchTranscript · FY2024 Q4 →
Show response

James framed new brands and shelf space as positive for industry but didn't address KO's specific plans. Pivoted to track record of scaling brands.

PEPPepsiCo7 questions · 6 reporting periods · 1 of 7 challenging
PEP company page →

Calendar 2026 Q3

I'd love to hear what you've learned from that experience working with Carlsberg

Geographic ExpansionCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2026 Q3 →
Show response

Laguarta said beer partnerships like Carlsberg add on-premise presence and in-home execution scale where PepsiCo is not the leader, citing share gains in the U.K.

I was wondering if you could give us an update on your efforts to integrate the food and beverage business in the U.S.

MarginSupply ChainTranscript · FY2026 Q3 →
Show response

Laguarta said physical integration of warehouses and transport is working, applies to some regions only, with details deferred to a future investor meeting.

Calendar 2026 Q2

are you perhaps overinvesting in the U.S., underinvesting internationally

ChallengingCapital AllocationGeographic ExpansionMarginTranscript · FY2026 Q2 →
Show response

Laguarta stressed international is not being starved of capital; U.S. productivity (automation, digitalization, combined U.S. logistics and mixing centers in Texoma) funds the U.S. transformation with positive returns.

Calendar 2026 Q1

talk about maybe the major buckets for productivity what you're doing maybe differently this year than in prior years

MarginCost PressureInnovation & R&DTranscript · FY2026 Q1 →
Show response

Steve cited cases per hour, headcount reductions, plant closures, SKU rationalization. Ramon added global shared services, AI in supply chain and transportation, digital ordering, and Texas supply chain integration tests.

Calendar 2025 Q4

what are you thinking about in terms of the macro conditions, in terms of your guidance for the year

MacroeconomicDemandGuidance ReliabilityTranscript · FY2025 Q4 →
Show response

Ramon described guidance as continuistic from Q4; Mexico improving, China positive, Middle East strong, Western Europe weaker, Brazil neutral. No macro improvement assumed.

Calendar 2025 Q3

that decision to go outside of the firm, to a very well-respected leader at your biggest customer

Cost PressureCapital AllocationTranscript · FY2025 Q3 →
Show response

Ramon described dual urgency on portfolio and cost transformation; technology investment over five years now enabling AI and automation. On CFO, thanked Jamie for 33 years; Steve brings right experience, skills, and culture fit for strategy 2030 execution.

Calendar 2025 Q2

beverages did much better than food. Can you talk maybe about -- a little bit about the drivers of why the beverages did so well

Geographic ExpansionCapital AllocationTranscript · FY2025 Q2 →
Show response

Ramon highlighted three international beverage platforms: no-sugar colas, energy (Sting), and hydration (Gatorade). On refranchising, framed NA integration as prioritizing cost reduction and growth opportunities over the next 3-4 years.

STZConstellation Brands7 questions · 7 reporting periods · 1 of 7 challenging
STZ company page →

Calendar 2026 Q3

what kind of market share it has, how incremental is it, and dream the dream

Competitive DynamicsRevenue GrowthTranscript · FY2027 Q2 →
Show response

Fink gave mid-teens first-half Victoria growth and described its distinct authentic-Mexican positioning, but gave no market-share figure or size target.

Calendar 2026 Q2

Are there a couple of things you can point out that are areas you'll be working on with Jack

Competitive DynamicsDemandTranscript · FY2027 Q1 →
Show response

Fink pointed to in-field execution, distribution gaps and pack-price architecture, but declined to be overly telegraphic on competitive ideas.

Calendar 2026 Q1

how have you adjusted your thinking on CapEx

Capex InvestmentCapital AllocationTranscript · FY2026 Q4 →
Show response

Bill highlighted $900M+ returned to shareholders in FY26 despite challenging environment. Garth noted FY26 CapEx came in significantly below starting expectations, will continue managing modularly. No guidance beyond FY27 but expects cyclical headwinds to ease.

Calendar 2025 Q4

Just wondering how -- what you've learned about the brand over this time, how incremental is it

Competitive DynamicsDemandTranscript · FY2026 Q3 →
Show response

Bill detailed Pacifico as #2 in California, skews younger, #1 social media share of voice, gained 1.5 points in on-premise. Following Modelo's west-to-east expansion playbook.

Calendar 2025 Q3

Corona Extra is down more than Coors Light or Miller Lite. Never seen that before

ChallengingCompetitive DynamicsDemandTranscript · FY2026 Q2 →
Show response

Bill reframed Corona as a brand family, Familiar is a top share gainer, Sunbrew is #1 new brand in dollars and #4 overall share gainer. Corona Extra's brand health metrics measured by intent to buy and first choice remain strong.

Calendar 2025 Q1

Are you today, and kind of going forward, more open to larger acquisitions

Capital AllocationM&ATranscript · FY2025 Q4 →
Show response

Garth outlined $9B operating cash flow and $6B FCF through FY28, committed to 3x leverage and 30% dividend payout. M&A remains last priority, focused on smaller plug-in opportunities.

Calendar 2024 Q4

can you just give us a sense of what -- and this is both on the beer side, what your internal inventories are for beer and your distributors

DemandCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2025 Q3 →
Show response

Bill noted slightly higher border-side inventory as tariff precaution, expects continued shelf gains in coming year though likely more normalized than double-digit prior year.

TAPMolson Coors Beverage Company6 questions · 6 reporting periods · 0 of 6 challenging
TAP company page →

Calendar 2026 Q2

I was wondering if you could maybe talk about Monaco in a little bit more depth, what surprised you

Show response

Rahul said Monaco is tracking slightly ahead of expectations on both top and bottom line, concentrated in about 5 states and convenience singles. Priority is preserving execution (80+ retained staff), then expanding channels and states in a measured, disciplined way.

Calendar 2026 Q1

can you tell us what you think a reasonable outcome for that brand is over the next 1 to 2 years?

Competitive DynamicsDemandTranscript · FY2026 Q1 →
Show response

Rahul said short/medium-term goal is stabilizing Miller Lite share, with Great Lakes area the primary challenge requiring targeted regional action. Feels good about current campaign and plans including Americas 250th activation leveraging taste and Americana angles. Believes regional execution rather than fundamental brand refresh is the current path forward.

Calendar 2025 Q4

how -- where did the idea or where did the change come from? And two, can you talk a little bit about execution of that?

Competitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2025 Q4 →
Show response

Rahul explained leadership changes brought sales, marketing, and Canadian leaders to the table. Regions reoriented in the U.S. with investments viewed as a collective pool optimized by geography for ROI. Brands show up one way nationally but executed differently by market. Distributor planning conversations already changed. Incentive plans redesigned with P&L accountability closest to market.

Calendar 2025 Q3

is kind of everything on the table, no sacred cows and that kind of approach

Competitive DynamicsCapital AllocationTranscript · FY2025 Q3 →
Show response

Rahul stated emphatically no constraints or sacred cows from the Board. Mandate is maximizing shareholder value. Acknowledged category challenges but pointed to great geographies with big profit pools. Will deploy balance sheet for portfolio augmentation while returning cash to shareholders.

Calendar 2025 Q2

what are the impacts on the industry and how can the industry address that?

DemandCompetitive DynamicsCapex InvestmentTranscript · FY2025 Q2 →
Show response

Gavin said shelf gains held with no significant fall 2025 activity expected in traditional beer space. Noted removing Pabst freed capacity for Peroni onshoring and Yuengling partnership expansion. Industry comps actually get tougher after July as industry improved from August onward last year.

Calendar 2024 Q4

can you give us a rough idea of what the economics look like and how this could potentially impact your income statement three, four, five years out

Show response

Gavin declined specific Fever-Tree financial projections but noted integration costs in the tens of millions. On tariffs, emphasized domestic production and sourcing. Tracey clarified 100% U.S. revenue recognition with EBITDA-level profit sharing.

Show 3 more companies
BF-BBrown–Forman3 questions · 3 reporting periods · 0 of 3 challenging
BF-B company page →

Calendar 2026 Q2

to what extent you think that price levels are a barrier to more spirits consumption in the U.S.

PricingDemandCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2026 Q4 →
Show response

Whiting argued spirits has been underpriced versus beer over the past decade, that the real pricing barrier is on-premise restaurant margins rather than off-premise prices, and that Brown-Forman's premium-plus exposure (e.g., the high-priced Jack Daniel's Heritage Barrel selling fast) means pricing is not the core demand challenge.

Calendar 2025 Q4

Does that mean that in the $20 to $30 area you're really not seeing any trade down at this point?

PricingDemandCapex InvestmentTranscript · FY2026 Q2 →
Show response

Lawson provided Nielsen 3-month value data by price tier: $100+ down 18% (small volume), $30-100 down 6-7%, $10-30 down about 4% (60-70% of market). Clear trade-down pattern. On A&P, Leanne confirmed philosophy of aligning with depletion-based growth, nearly $100M added to brand investment over last 5 years. Lawson acknowledged can't advertise out of a 4% TDS decline.

Calendar 2024 Q4

Can you talk about Jack Daniel's Tennessee Whiskey in the U.S. and the sort of measures that you're taking to

Competitive DynamicsInnovation & R&DTranscript · FY2025 Q2 →
Show response

Lawson detailed McLaren Racing activations, Shaboozey music partnership, media mix changes, and Jack & Coke. Brand health metrics like penetration and buzz starting to move in right direction.

MNSTMonster Beverage3 questions · 3 reporting periods · 0 of 3 challenging
MNST company page →

Calendar 2026 Q2

I just wanted to touch, if you could touch on the Marriott win.

Competitive DynamicsGeographic ExpansionTranscript · FY2026 Q2 →
Show response

Hilton spoke to the strengthened relationship with Coke's new C-suite and the complementary FSOP opportunity but declined to size the Marriott deal or detail how it came about.

Calendar 2026 Q1

So I was wondering if you can talk a little bit about the drivers of that acceleration

Competitive DynamicsProduct LaunchTranscript · FY2026 Q1 →
Show response

Hilton credited the Monster playbook but noted work needed on strategic brands (Bang, NOS, Full Throttle). Highlighted FLRT for the female category and Storm for wellness, plus affordable brands Predator and Fury in emerging markets.

Calendar 2025 Q2

you mentioned something about I thought changing the visual identity on the Ultra line

Product LaunchCompetitive DynamicsTranscript · FY2025 Q2 →
Show response

CEO explained new silver claw branding for Ultra line with separate coolers, commercial stacks, and floor displays. Building on viral Zero Ultra campaign from EMEA spreading to US. Zero Sugar flavors proposition for in-store merchandising.

KDPKeurig Dr Pepper2 questions · 2 reporting periods · 0 of 2 challenging
KDP company page →

Calendar 2026 Q2

can you remind us what your ownership stake is, how it hits your income statement?

Capital AllocationDemandTranscript · FY2026 Q2 →
Show response

Tim confirmed the 36% Nutrabolt stake covering C4 and Bloom, plus board seats, and expressed bullishness on continued brand growth.

Calendar 2025 Q2

I was just wondering if you could talk to us a little bit about the pricing dynamics in the U.S. on liquid refreshment beverages

Show response

Tim noted lower-income consumer constrained with pullbacks in QSR and convenience channels. Consumers gravitating to value channels. Categories remain durable with strong portfolio momentum.

Challenge rate by company

Every company this analyst questioned, most questions first. A company-level rate is shown from 3 questions; below that it is withheld.

CompanyQuestionsChallenge rate
PG The Procter & Gamble Company911%1 of 9 questions
CL Colgate-Palmolive70%none of 7 questions
KO The Coca-Cola Company70%none of 7 questions
PEP PepsiCo714%1 of 7 questions
STZ Constellation Brands714%1 of 7 questions
TAP Molson Coors Beverage Company60%none of 6 questions
BF-B Brown–Forman30%none of 3 questions
MNST Monster Beverage30%none of 3 questions
KDP Keurig Dr Pepper2—Rate withheld: fewer than 3 questions
  • PG
    The Procter & Gamble Company · 9 questions
    11%1 of 9 questions
  • CL
    Colgate-Palmolive · 7 questions
    0%none of 7 questions
  • KO
    The Coca-Cola Company · 7 questions
    0%none of 7 questions
  • PEP
    PepsiCo · 7 questions
    14%1 of 7 questions
  • STZ
    Constellation Brands · 7 questions
    14%1 of 7 questions
  • TAP
    Molson Coors Beverage Company · 6 questions
    0%none of 6 questions
  • BF-B
    Brown–Forman · 3 questions
    0%none of 3 questions
  • MNST
    Monster Beverage · 3 questions
    0%none of 3 questions
  • KDP
    Keurig Dr Pepper · 2 questions
    —rate withheld: under 3 questions

Activity by reporting period

Questions recorded for each calendar quarter that companies’ reporting periods map to (not the call date), with the challenge rate for that period. Periods inside the range with no questions are shown as “No questions recorded”.

Questions by calendar reporting period
Calendar periodQuestionsChallenge rateCompanies
2024 Q310%none of 1 question1
2024 Q460%none of 6 questions6
2025 Q140%none of 4 questions4
2025 Q270%none of 7 questions7
2025 Q3617%1 of 6 questions6
2025 Q470%none of 7 questions7
2026 Q180%none of 8 questions7
2026 Q2922%2 of 9 questions9
2026 Q330%none of 3 questions2
  1. 2024 Q31 question · challenge rate 0% (none of 1 question) · 1 company
  2. 2024 Q46 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 6 questions) · 6 companies
  3. 2025 Q14 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 4 questions) · 4 companies
  4. 2025 Q27 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 7 questions) · 7 companies
  5. 2025 Q36 questions · challenge rate 17% (1 of 6 questions) · 6 companies
  6. 2025 Q47 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 7 questions) · 7 companies
  7. 2026 Q18 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 8 questions) · 7 companies
  8. 2026 Q29 questions · challenge rate 22% (2 of 9 questions) · 9 companies
  9. 2026 Q33 questions · challenge rate 0% (none of 3 questions) · 2 companies

Topics

Topics tagged on this analyst’s questions.

  • Competitive Dynamics25
  • Demand21
  • Geographic Expansion10
  • Product Launch10
  • Capital Allocation8
  • Pricing6
  • Innovation & R&D6
  • Capex Investment4
  • Revenue Growth3
  • Macroeconomic3
Show all 19 topics
  • Margin3
  • Cost Pressure3
  • M&A3
  • Inventory1
  • Supply Chain1
  • Cloud & AI1
  • Fx1
  • Guidance Reliability1
  • Trade Tariffs1